Checklist · Environmental

Obtaining a Permit and Responding to a Notice of Violation: A Practical Checklist

33 U.S.C. § 1342

Type
Checklist
Jurisdiction
National
Date
2024-11-26
Topic
Environmental

This checklist runs the four operations in environmental compliance. Part A obtains a permit, from authorization mapping through issuance and appeal. Part B builds the compliance program — reading the permit, the calendar, and the applicability protocol that prevents the most expensive category of enforcement. Part C handles inspections. Part D responds to a notice of violation, hour by hour and then week by week, through penalty negotiation and consent decree terms. Separate parts cover self-disclosure, citizen suit notices, permit renewal and transfer, and transactional diligence. A final part lists the actions that convert a civil matter into a criminal one.

Obtaining a Permit and Responding to a Notice of Violation: A Practical Checklist

Environmental > Permitting and Compliance | Published 26 November 2024 - Updated 26 July 2026 | UpLaw - uplaw.us

Part A — Obtaining a Permit

A1. Map the Authorizations

A2. Prepare

  • [ ] Hold a pre-application meeting and record what the agency identifies as its concerns.
  • [ ] Commission the technical work: control technology determination and modeling for air; discharge characterization and receiving water analysis for water; design, closure, post-closure, and financial assurance for waste.
  • [ ] Disclose fully. Disclosure is what makes the permit shield protective; omission is not, and can be an independent violation.
  • [ ] Check the application for completeness against the agency's checklist. Incompleteness restarts the clock.
  • [ ] Obtain required certifications and signatures, including engineering certifications.

A3. Public Process and Issuance

  • [ ] Track the draft permit publication and comment period under 40 C.F.R. part 124.
  • [ ] Read every comment and respond substantively — issues not raised are generally waived on later review.
  • [ ] Attend the hearing if one is held.
  • [ ] Review the final permit line by line before the appeal window closes.
  • [ ] Appeal any condition you cannot live with, administratively then judicially, on the record and within the deadline. Unchallenged conditions bind for the term.
  • [ ] Calendar the expiration and the renewal application deadline the day the permit issues.

Part B — The Compliance Program

B1. Read the Permit

  • [ ] Cover page: permittee, facility, number, effective date, expiration date.
  • [ ] Authorized activities — and by implication what is not authorized.
  • [ ] Limits by parameter, with averaging periods. A daily maximum and a monthly average are separate obligations.
  • [ ] Monitoring: parameter, frequency, sample type, method.
  • [ ] Recordkeeping: what, and for how long.
  • [ ] Reporting: what, to whom, on what form, by when — including immediate notification triggers measured in hours.
  • [ ] Standard conditions: duty to comply, duty to mitigate, proper operation and maintenance, duty to provide information, inspection and entry, signatory requirements.
  • [ ] Special conditions, compliance schedules, and required studies.

B2. Build One Calendar

Every entry needs a named owner and a named backup.

  • [ ] Daily and weekly inspection rounds with a logbook.
  • [ ] Monitoring and sampling by parameter and frequency.
  • [ ] Quarterly reports.
  • [ ] Annual compliance certifications, signed by a responsible official who has seen the data.
  • [ ] Waste accumulation start dates and shipment deadlines by container.
  • [ ] Manifest reconciliation and exception reporting.
  • [ ] Tank testing and inspection intervals.
  • [ ] Training refreshers with sign-in sheets.
  • [ ] Plan reviews: pollution prevention, spill prevention, contingency.
  • [ ] Permit expirations and renewal application deadlines, with a one-year reminder.
  • [ ] Financial assurance renewals and fee payments.

B3. The Applicability Protocol

⭐ The single control that prevents the most expensive cases.

  • [ ] Standing rule: no construction, modification, process change, or equipment replacement proceeds without a written applicability analysis.
  • [ ] Compare projected actual emissions or discharges against the baseline.
  • [ ] State the methodology and the data relied on.
  • [ ] Identify any exclusion claimed and why it applies.
  • [ ] Signed, dated, retained.
  • [ ] Consider asking the agency in writing where the answer is genuinely unclear — a documented inquiry is powerful evidence of good faith.

Part C — Inspections

C1. Standing Protocol

  • [ ] One named greeter, with a backup. Everyone else refers.
  • [ ] Records organized, in one place, retrievable in minutes.
  • [ ] Staff instructed: answer within your own knowledge, factually; say "I don't know" when you do not; do not speculate or characterize compliance.
  • [ ] Counsel's number posted.

C2. During

  • [ ] Accompany the inspector at all times.
  • [ ] Take the same photographs the inspector takes.
  • [ ] Take split samples whenever the inspector samples.
  • [ ] Keep a contemporaneous log: areas entered, questions asked, documents requested, samples taken, times.
  • [ ] Produce what is requested; volunteer nothing.
  • [ ] Note staff statements verbatim where possible.
  • [ ] Do not refuse entry — permits and statutes provide inspection authority, and refusal is itself a violation. Raise scope objections politely, with counsel.

C3. After

  • [ ] Written debrief the same day, while memories are fresh.
  • [ ] Fix immediately anything that can be fixed.
  • [ ] Correct any inaccurate statement in writing, promptly — an uncorrected inaccuracy becomes an allegation under 18 U.S.C. § 1001.
  • [ ] Respond in writing to the inspection report.
  • [ ] ⚠️ Never alter a record before or after an inspection — 18 U.S.C. § 1519.

Part D — Notice of Violation

D1. Week One

  • [ ] Record the date received and the response deadline.
  • [ ] Issue a written preservation hold covering documents, monitoring data, maintenance logs, and email. Suspend routine destruction.
  • [ ] Engage counsel; conduct the review at counsel's direction.
  • [ ] Verify every allegation independently against the underlying data and against the permit's actual text.
  • [ ] Determine whether any violation is continuing. If so, stop it now — penalties accrue daily under provisions including 33 U.S.C. § 1319.
  • [ ] Assess criminal exposure before anyone speaks. Knowing violations are felonies; negligent violations of the water statute are misdemeanors.
  • [ ] Instruct staff to route all agency contact to one person.
  • [ ] Notify insurers per policy terms.

D2. The Response Letter

  • [ ] On time, in writing.
  • [ ] Accurate as to what is known; explicit about what is still under investigation.
  • [ ] No characterizations that may later prove wrong.
  • [ ] Describes corrective action already taken, with dates.
  • [ ] Proposes a schedule for anything not yet complete.
  • [ ] Requests a meeting.
  • [ ] Remember: this letter is quoted in every subsequent document.

D3. Penalty Mitigation Package

  • [ ] Economic benefit analysis — what was actually saved, computed conservatively. This is the practical floor.
  • [ ] Gravity mitigation — absence of harm, absence of exceedance where the violation is administrative, small magnitude, short duration.
  • [ ] Compliance history, if favorable.
  • [ ] Good faith: pre-notice self-audit, prompt correction with dates, the written compliance program, training records, calendar completion rates.
  • [ ] Ability to pay documentation if relevant.
  • [ ] Supplemental environmental project proposal, where agency policy permits.
  • [ ] A named accountable person and a credible schedule.

D4. Consent Decree Negotiation

Negotiate in this order.

  • [ ] 1. The compliance schedule. Achievable milestones with realistic dates. This matters more than the penalty.
  • [ ] 2. Stipulated penalties. They operate automatically for years.
  • [ ] 3. Force majeure definition — what excuses a missed date.
  • [ ] 4. Scope of injunctive work — one unit or the facility, and whether it binds future operations.
  • [ ] 5. Termination provisions — what must be demonstrated, for how long. Insist on a clean exit.
  • [ ] 6. Reporting burden, which is a real recurring cost.
  • [ ] 7. The civil penalty.
  • [ ] Confirm whether the resolution binds both state and federal authorities; a resolution with one may not resolve the other.
  • [ ] Expect judicial decrees to be lodged publicly with a comment period.

Part E — Self-Disclosure

  • [ ] Establish the facts completely before deciding.
  • [ ] Confirm the discovery was voluntary — not from an inspection or a required monitoring event.
  • [ ] Confirm prompt disclosure, correction, and prevention of recurrence.
  • [ ] Understand that gravity-based penalties may be reduced or eliminated but economic benefit generally is not.
  • [ ] Weigh: likelihood of independent discovery; whether the violation is ongoing; criminal exposure; sector enforcement attention; any pending transaction.
  • [ ] ⚠️ Never disclose without counsel. A disclosure is an admission, and an incomplete one is worse than none.
  • [ ] Check the state policy separately; conditions differ.

Part F — Citizen Suit Notice

Part G — Renewal and Modification

  • [ ] Calendar the renewal application deadline — typically 180 days before expiration — with a one-year reminder.
  • [ ] File on time. A timely application generally continues the existing permit until renewal issues; a late one can leave the facility operating unpermitted, converting routine operations into violations.
  • [ ] Review the outgoing permit for conditions that no longer fit the operation, and propose changes with supporting data.
  • [ ] Address any rule vacated or changed since issuance — the condition stands until the permit is modified.
  • [ ] Disclose accurately in the renewal; the permit shield depends on it.
  • [ ] Request a modification rather than deviating, whenever operations change.
  • [ ] Track whether the modification is minor or major — the latter triggers public process.

Part H — Transactions

  • [ ] Confirm whether each permit transfers: administratively on notice, with agency approval, or not at all. Do this before signing.
  • [ ] Diligence list: every permit and expiration; notices of violation, orders, and consent decrees, which bind successors; five years of monitoring data read for exceedance patterns; the air modification history; waste generator status and manifests; tanks; financial assurance; pending applications; and the compliance calendar itself.
  • [ ] Complete all appropriate inquiries before closing to preserve the innocent landowner, contiguous property, and bona fide prospective purchaser defenses to liability under 42 U.S.C. § 9607, with definitions at 42 U.S.C. § 9601 and response procedures at 40 C.F.R. part 300.
  • [ ] Understand the continuing obligations the defenses impose after closing.
  • [ ] Allocate: representations with survival periods; indemnities carved out of liability caps; escrow or holdback; environmental insurance; price adjustment.
  • [ ] Plan for day one — an operating facility that cannot lawfully operate on closing day is a valuation error.

Part I — Actions That Convert Civil Into Criminal

  • [ ] Altering, backdating, or destroying a record after a notice, an inspection, or a subpoena — 18 U.S.C. § 1519.
  • [ ] Making a false statement to an inspector or in a report — 18 U.S.C. § 1001.
  • [ ] Signing a compliance certification without seeing the underlying data.
  • [ ] Adjusting data to resolve a discrepancy.
  • [ ] Instructing staff to be unavailable or unhelpful.
  • [ ] Continuing a known violation after being told of it.
  • [ ] Bypassing treatment without the permit's required notice.
  • [ ] Disposing of waste off-manifest.
  • [ ] Concealing a spill or missing an immediate-notification deadline.
  • [ ] Operating after a permit lapses because nobody filed the renewal.

Part J — Quarterly Five-Minute Review

  • [ ] Every permit's expiration date confirmed; renewal reminders live.
  • [ ] Calendar completion rate for the quarter — any misses, and why.
  • [ ] Every calendar entry has a current owner and a backup who still works here.
  • [ ] Any project in the quarter that proceeded without a written applicability analysis.
  • [ ] Any exceedance reported late.
  • [ ] Any inspection this quarter, and whether the debrief and corrections were documented.
  • [ ] Training current.
  • [ ] Financial assurance and fees current.

Part K — The Annual Self-Audit

Run this once a year, at counsel's direction where privilege matters. It is what converts a penalty negotiation.

K1. Scope and Setup

  • [ ] Engagement letter from counsel describing the legal purpose.
  • [ ] Scope: all media, all units, all authorizations.
  • [ ] Assemble the permit binder, the calendar, and the last twelve months of monitoring and reporting.
  • [ ] Identify the personnel who actually perform each obligation, by name.

K2. Test the Calendar Against Reality

  • [ ] For each monitoring obligation: was every required sample taken, on time, by the required method?
  • [ ] For each report: filed by the deadline, on the correct form, complete?
  • [ ] For each immediate-notification event in the period: reported within the permit's window?
  • [ ] For each annual certification: signed by a responsible official who reviewed the data?
  • [ ] For waste: accumulation dates observed, containers labeled and dated, manifests reconciled, exception reports filed?
  • [ ] For tanks and equipment: testing and inspections at the required intervals?
  • [ ] For plans: reviewed and certified on schedule?
  • [ ] For training: current, with records?

K3. Test the Limits

  • [ ] Compare every reported value against the applicable limit and averaging period.
  • [ ] Identify exceedances, and whether each was reported.
  • [ ] Identify near-misses that indicate a process trending toward a violation.
  • [ ] Verify the analytical methods used match those the permit requires.
  • [ ] Verify the sampling locations match the permit's description.

K4. Test the Applicability Record

  • [ ] List every project, modification, process change, and equipment replacement in the period.
  • [ ] For each, is there a written applicability analysis? If not, that is the first finding.
  • [ ] For each analysis, is the methodology stated and the data retained?
  • [ ] Has any change occurred that would alter waste generator status?

K5. Report and Remediate

  • [ ] Written memorandum: scope, method, findings, remediation with dates, open items with owners.
  • [ ] Correct what can be corrected immediately.
  • [ ] Decide the disclosure question deliberately, with counsel.
  • [ ] Update the calendar and the protocol to prevent recurrence.
  • [ ] Present findings to management on a stated cadence.
  • [ ] Calendar next year's audit.

⭐ Two metrics to report every year: calendar completion rate, and the number of projects that proceeded without a written applicability analysis. Those two numbers predict enforcement exposure better than anything else a facility tracks.

Part L — Deadline Table

Item Typical timing Consequence of missing it
Permit renewal application Often 180 days before expiration Operating without a permit; every discharge a violation
Immediate exceedance notification Hours, per permit Separate reporting violation
Written follow-up report Commonly 5 days Separate violation
Discharge monitoring report Monthly or quarterly Reporting violation; builds the enforcement record
Annual compliance certification Annual Violation; false certification is criminal
Waste accumulation limit By generator status Storage without a permit
Manifest exception report Per regulation Reporting violation
Notice of violation response As stated in the notice Waiver of the chance to shape the record
Citizen suit notice period 60 days The window to become compliant or trigger a government action
Permit appeal Short, per program Conditions become final for the term
Consent decree milestones Per decree Automatic stipulated penalties

Part M — Roles and Ownership Sheet

Fill this in and post it. Ambiguity about ownership is the root cause of most administrative violations.

Obligation Primary owner Backup Frequency Where recorded Last verified
Sampling — [parameter]
Discharge monitoring report
Immediate exceedance notification
Air monitoring and recordkeeping
Annual compliance certification signatory
Waste container labeling and dating
Manifest reconciliation
Tank testing
Stormwater inspections
Plan reviews and certifications
Training delivery and records
Permit renewal filings
Fee and financial assurance payments
Inspector greeting and escort
Preservation hold authority
Agency communications
  • [ ] Every row has a named person, not a department.
  • [ ] Every row has a backup who currently works here.
  • [ ] Reviewed when anyone in the table leaves or changes roles — the single most common cause of a missed obligation.

Related Documents