Guide · Labor and Employment

Worker Classification: A Comprehensive Guide to Employee and Independent Contractor Status

29 U.S.C. § 1002(6)

Type
Guide
Jurisdiction
National
Date
2023-06-26
Topic
Labor and Employment

Worker classification is the single legal question that decides whether a person earns a minimum wage, collects overtime, participates in a retirement plan, can sue for discrimination, can unionize, and whether the company writing the checks owes years of back payroll taxes. This UpLaw guide explains why there is no unified answer: the Fair Labor Standards Act uses a broad "suffer or permit" economic-reality test that the Department of Labor has rewritten twice in three years; the IRS applies a common-law control test rooted in Rev. Rul. 87-41 and softened by Section 530 relief; California and a growing number of states impose the presumptive ABC test after Dynamex and AB5; the NLRA and ERISA each run their own common-law analyses; and copyright and patent law add an ownership overlay that can strip a company of the very work it paid for. It traces what the leading cases actually held, from Rutherford Food and CCNV v. Reid through Nationwide v. Darden, Vizcaino v. Microsoft, and the gig-economy fights that produced Proposition 22. It maps joint-employment exposure for staffing agencies, franchisors, and platforms, and it prices out the cost of getting classification wrong: back wages, liquidated damages, employer FICA, benefit restoration, statutory penalties, and class and collective exposure. It closes with a practical program for structuring a genuine contractor relationship, papering it correctly, auditing an existing workforce, and remediating misclassification without turning a compliance project into a lawsuit.

Worker Classification: A Comprehensive Guide to Employee and Independent Contractor Status

Labor and Employment > Worker Classification | Published 26 June 2023 - Updated 31 March 2025 | UpLaw - uplaw.us

One worker. One set of facts. Five different agencies, and five different answers. Worker classification is the rare legal question where the same person can be an employee for wage-and-hour purposes, an independent contractor for tax purposes, an employee for benefits purposes, and a nonemployee for labor-law purposes -- all at once, all lawfully.

The full text of this document is available to Executive subscribers and above. See plans.