Article · Civil Rights

Where You May Speak and Who May Stop You: How the First Amendment Actually Applies

42 U.S.C. § 1983

Type
Article
Jurisdiction
National
Date
2023-09-26
Topic
Civil Rights

The First Amendment protects a great deal of speech and almost none of the things people assume it protects. This article explains what it actually does — restrain the government, and only the government — and how the protection varies enormously depending on where you are standing. It walks through the forum framework that decides most protest cases, the difference between a content-based rule and a time-place-and-manner rule, and why permit schemes are constitutional even though prior restraints generally are not. It covers the narrow categories of unprotected speech, why incitement almost never applies to angry rhetoric, and what a true threat now requires. Later parts address arrests at protests, retaliatory arrest claims, the practical reality of qualified immunity, filming police, and what happens when the venue is a shopping mall, a university, or a social media platform. Examples run throughout, including a worked scenario tracing a single march from permit application to federal lawsuit.

Where You May Speak and Who May Stop You: How the First Amendment Actually Applies

Civil Rights > Speech, Assembly, and Protest | Published 26 September 2023 - Updated 6 September 2025 | UpLaw - uplaw.us


The sentence everyone gets wrong

"That violates my First Amendment rights."

Said to a manager. Said to a moderator. Said to an employer, a homeowners association, a bartender, and a website. Almost always wrong.

The full text of this document is available to Executive subscribers and above. See plans.