Article · Litigation

The Courthouse Without Lawyers: How Small Claims Cases Are Actually Won

15 U.S.C. § 1673

Type
Article
Jurisdiction
National
Date
2024-05-26
Topic
Litigation

Small claims court is the only American courtroom designed for people without lawyers, and the cases that lose there almost never lose on the law. This article explains what actually decides them. It covers the three questions that dispose of most cases before any argument about the merits: whether the right defendant was named, whether the amount fits the court's limit, and whether service was accomplished correctly. It explains how to build a case out of documents rather than indignation, what a judge is actually listening for, and the five-minute structure that presents a claim clearly. It then turns to the part nobody warns about — that winning produces a piece of paper, not money — and covers the collection machinery, the exemptions that protect a debtor, and the judgment debtor examination that makes collection possible. It closes with what small claims cannot do, and when to go somewhere else.

The Courthouse Without Lawyers: How Small Claims Cases Are Actually Won

Litigation > Small Claims and Self-Representation | Published 26 May 2024 - Updated 10 May 2025 | UpLaw - uplaw.us

The contractor took $4,200 to replace a bathroom floor. He removed the old tile, discovered — or said he discovered — a problem with the subfloor, asked for another $1,800, received it, worked for two more days, and then stopped answering the phone. That was in March. It is now October, and the bathroom has a plywood floor and a toilet sitting in the hallway.

The full text of this document is available to Executive subscribers and above. See plans.