The Investor Claim and Securities Arbitration Toolkit

Business > Investments and Securities | Published 25 October 2024 - Updated 17 October 2025 | UpLaw - uplaw.us

⚠ Two clocks run from the events rather than from discovery: the forum's six-year eligibility rule and the applicable limitations period. Tool 1 exists to capture them on day one.

---

Tool 1 — Intake and eligibility sheet

Field	Entry
Customer name, age, occupation
Account opened (date) and account type
Firm and representative names
Broker, investment adviser, or both
Stated objectives at opening
Amount invested; source of funds
Dates of the transactions at issue
Eligibility deadline (6 years from events)
Applicable limitations period
Account still open? Assets moved?
Complaint made to the firm (date, response)
Regulator complaint filed?
Disciplinary records checked (date)

⚠ Do not liquidate or transfer before the damages analysis. Selling can convert a recoverable loss into a realized one.

---

Tool 2 — Account records demand

[Date] — Request for account records — [name], account [___]

Please provide within thirty days:

1. The new account form and every subsequent profile or update, each dated.
2. All statements from opening to the present.
3. All trade confirmations.
4. All correspondence, including email and text messages.
5. All marketing, offering, and disclosure materials provided for each investment.
6. All documents I signed, each dated.
7. Any recordings of telephone calls with me.
8. A statement of all commissions, markups, fees, and other compensation received by the firm and the representative in connection with my account.

Please confirm receipt and the date the records will be provided.

⭐ Item 8 is resisted most and matters most: compensation supplies the motive that connects the recommendation to the defect.

---

Tool 3 — Public record check

Item	Found	Notes
Registration history and prior firms
Customer complaints, allegations and dispositions
Regulatory actions
Criminal and civil judicial disclosures
Financial disclosures
Outside business activities
Firm regulatory actions and awards
State regulator records

⭐ Run this before opening an account, and again the day a problem appears. A pattern of prior complaints is both a warning and later evidence of what the firm knew.

---

Tool 4 — Account timeline

Date	Event	Value	Deposit / withdrawal	Source document

☐ Account opened and profile signed, with objectives quoted. ☐ Each profile update, with what changed. ☐ Each purchase, with solicitation status and compensation. ☐ Each statement showing concentration crossing a threshold. ☐ Each complaint or question, and the response. ☐ Account closure or transfer.

⭐ This is the exhibit the panel will actually use.

---

Tool 5 — Concentration and cost computation

Quarter	Value	Largest position %	Sector %	Illiquid %	Purchases	Turnover (annualized)	Costs	Cost-to-equity (annualized)

Analytical guides: a single position above twenty percent invites scrutiny and above forty is hard to defend for an income-oriented customer; turnover above two is high and above six is very high; cost-to-equity above ten percent means the account must earn that much before the customer earns anything. ⚠ Guides, not thresholds — the question is always suitability for this documented profile.

---

Tool 6 — Statement of claim outline

1. The customer. Age, occupation, financial circumstances, and what was said about needs and objectives at the outset. 2. The relationship. Firm, representative, account type, and whether the representative acted as a broker under 15 U.S.C. § 78o or as an adviser subject to 15 U.S.C. § 80b-6. 3. What was recommended and purchased. Each transaction, with date, amount, and compensation. 4. What went wrong. Concentration, unsuitability, unauthorized trading, excessive trading, misrepresentation, or products sold outside the firm. 5. The numbers. Concentration, turnover, cost-to-equity, and the benchmark comparison. 6. Claims. Unsuitability and best interest; breach of fiduciary duty; over-concentration; unauthorized trading; churning; misrepresentation; failure to supervise; selling away; control person liability under 15 U.S.C. § 78t; state securities claims; negligence and breach of contract. 7. Damages. The measure, the number, and the request for interest, costs, and fees. 8. Exhibits. The new account form and the concentration chart.

⭐ Lead with the account's construction against the profile. Arbitrators decide on the facts; the legal labels matter less than in court.

---

Tool 7 — Discovery request set

From the firm, beyond the automatic list:

☐ Written supervisory procedures in effect during the relevant period. ☐ Every exception report that flagged the account — concentration, turnover, cost-to-equity, senior investor alerts. ☐ The supervisory response to each exception, and any escalation. ☐ Branch inspection reports covering the office and period. ☐ Correspondence and electronic communication review logs. ☐ The representative's outside business activity disclosures and private securities transaction approvals. ☐ Prior customer complaints against the representative and their dispositions. ☐ Any heightened supervision plan. ☐ Compensation records for the products at issue. ☐ Product due diligence files and any internal risk ratings. ☐ Training materials on the products at issue.

⚠ Expect objections. A specific, justified request is granted far more often than a broad one.

---

Tool 8 — Expert instructions

Damages expert, deliverables:

☐ Month-by-month reconstruction of holdings from statements. ☐ Concentration by security, sector, and product type at each period end. ☐ Turnover and cost-to-equity, annualized, with the computation shown. ☐ Total costs as a percentage of average account value. ☐ Well-managed portfolio benchmark matched to the documented objectives, with the allocation stated and justified. ☐ Actual versus benchmark, net of deposits and withdrawals. ☐ Sensitivity analysis under an alternative benchmark.

Standards:

⭐ Arithmetic that fits on one page. Panels discount what they cannot follow. ☐ Conservative, explicit assumptions. ☐ Firm documents rather than reconstructed data. ☐ Concede what is not provable. ☐ ⚠ Do not have the damages expert opine that conduct was unsuitable — that is an industry practices opinion, and combining the roles weakens both.

---

Tool 9 — Hearing exhibit list

☐ Statement of claim with the timeline. ☐ Indexed exhibit binder tabbed to the timeline. ☐ Concentration chart over time, with the stated objectives printed above it. ⭐ The single most valuable exhibit. ☐ Cost summary on one page. ☐ Benchmark comparison on one page. ☐ Damages summary. ☐ New account form, enlarged. ☐ Confirmations showing solicitation status. ☐ Exception reports and supervisory responses. ☐ Representative's disciplinary history. ☐ Witness list with three points each. ☐ Cross-examination outlines keyed to exhibits. ☐ Reasoned award request confirmed on the record.

---

Tool 10 — Damages summary

Line	Item	Amount
1	Total deposited
2	Total withdrawn
3	Ending value
4	Out-of-pocket (1 − 2 − 3)
5	Benchmark ending value
6	Well-managed portfolio measure (5 − 3)
7	Commissions, markups, fees (churning cases)
8	Interest
9	Offsets — other gains, tax benefits
10	Claim value

⚠ Compute from the investment, not from the account's peak value.

---

Tool 11 — Settlement and expungement

☐ Confirm who pays and what approval is required. ☐ Confirm the payment deadline — generally thirty days, with licensing consequences for non-payment. ☐ Draft the release to cover only what was claimed. ☐ Address confidentiality narrowly, with carve-outs for advisers and compelled disclosure. ☐ Address tax treatment. See tax controversy for individuals. ☐ ⚠ Negotiate the expungement term consciously. An agreement not to oppose removes the complaint from the record future customers will consult. ☐ Participate in any expungement hearing unless the settlement precludes it. ☐ Confirm the award under 9 U.S.C. § 9 if payment is not made; vacatur is confined to 9 U.S.C. § 10.

---

Tool 12 — Regulator complaint

Complaint to [state securities regulator / federal agency]

Complainant: [name, address, telephone] Subject: [representative name and identification number]; [firm name and identification number] Account: [number, opened date] What occurred: [factual chronology with dates and amounts] Documents enclosed: new account form, statements, confirmations, correspondence, offering materials Amount at issue: $[___] Relief requested: investigation and appropriate action

☐ File in parallel with a claim; it creates a file but does not substitute for a claim. ☐ Keep the complaint and any response; both may be discoverable and useful.

---

Tool 13 — Whistleblower submission outline

For an employee or insider with original information about securities violations, under 15 U.S.C. § 78u-6.

☐ Submit through the prescribed channel; ⚠ the channel determines eligibility and the scope of anti-retaliation protection. ☐ Describe the conduct with specificity — who, what, when, and how you know. ☐ Identify documents, without taking privileged or unlawfully obtained material. ☐ State whether the information was previously reported internally, and when. ☐ Consider counsel; anonymous submission is permitted with representation. ☐ Preserve evidence of any adverse employment action following the report. See whistleblower and retaliation claims and reporting misconduct and preserving a retaliation claim.

---

Tool 14 — Issuer offering compliance checklist

☐ Determine whether the instrument is a security — 15 U.S.C. § 77b and SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946). ⚠ Revenue shares, profit participations, and membership interests frequently are. ☐ Register, or identify a specific exemption and satisfy every condition — 15 U.S.C. § 77e; rules at 17 C.F.R. part 230. ☐ Verify accreditation where required, and document it. ☐ Avoid general solicitation where prohibited — including seminars, websites, and social media. ☐ Prepare adequate disclosure; antifraud provisions at 15 U.S.C. § 77q and 15 U.S.C. § 78j apply to exempt offerings. ☐ Make state notice filings. ☐ Confirm anyone selling is registered; transaction-based compensation to an unregistered finder is a violation. ☐ For public issuers: periodic reporting under 15 U.S.C. § 78m, insider reporting under 15 U.S.C. § 78p, and an insider trading policy.

See starting and running a small business.

---

Tool 15 — Prevention card

Before opening an account: check the disciplinary records; ask whether the person is a broker, an adviser, or both; ask exactly how they are paid; ask what happens if the money is needed in two years; read the arbitration clause and the discretionary authority provision.

Ongoing: update the profile in writing whenever circumstances change; read statements quarterly for concentration, turnover, and fees; question anything that cannot be explained in two sentences; refuse anything sold outside the firm; name a trusted contact; keep every statement.

Red flags: ⚠ guaranteed returns; urgency or confidentiality; checks payable to anyone but the firm or custodian; statements not from the custodian; unauthorized trades on a confirmation; a recommendation to roll a plan balance into a commission product; borrowing against the account to buy more of the same thing.

---

Tool 16 — Deadline calendar

Item	Timing
Arbitration eligibility	6 years from the events
State securities claims	Varies, frequently shorter
Federal fraud claim	Statutory limitations and repose
Registration statement claim	Short period from discovery, with outer repose
Award payment	Generally 30 days
Motion to vacate	3 months — 9 U.S.C. § 10

---

Tool 17 — Authority reference

Regulation: 15 U.S.C. § 78o · 15 U.S.C. § 80b-6 · 17 C.F.R. part 275 · 17 C.F.R. part 240

Registration and fraud: 15 U.S.C. § 77a · § 77b · § 77e · § 77k · § 77l · § 77o · § 77q · § 78j · § 78t · § 78u-4

Cases: Howey (1946) · Hochfelder (1976) · Chiarella (1980) · Dirks (1983) · Basic (1988) · Reves (1990) · O'Hagan (1997) · Dura (2005) · Tellabs (2007) · Morrison (2010) · Matrixx (2011) · Janus Capital (2011) · Salman (2016) · Kokesh (2017) · Liu (2020) · Slack (2023) · Jarkesy (2024)

---

Tool 18 — Routing table

If the situation involves…	Start here
An arbitration clause generally	Arbitration
A class action against an issuer	Class actions and mass claims
Outright fraud or a Ponzi scheme	Consumer fraud and financial exploitation
An older investor	Elder financial exploitation
A retirement plan	Employee benefits and ERISA
An agent under a power of attorney	Powers of attorney and advance directives
Beneficiary designations	Life insurance claims and beneficiary disputes
An estate	Probate and estate administration
A bank account or transfer	Consumer banking and payments
Raising capital	Starting and running a small business
Employment retaliation after reporting	Whistleblower and retaliation claims
Tax treatment of a recovery	Tax controversy for individuals

Tool 19 — Product diligence questions

Non-traded programs: upfront cost as a percentage; whether distributions were funded from operations or returned capital; represented versus actual liquidity; how valuation was determined and by whom.

Annuities: surrender period and charge schedule; whether an existing contract was replaced and at what cost; riders and their annual cost; whether the surrender period extends past life expectancy.

Structured products: the payoff formula; issuer credit exposure; the secondary market, if any; whether it was described as principal-protected and whether that was accurate.

Leveraged and inverse products: holding period; whether the daily-reset characteristic was disclosed; whether the firm's own guidance restricted holding periods.

Margin: the maintenance requirement; whether a call issued and with what notice; which positions were liquidated and in what order.

Private placements: the exemption claimed; accreditation and how it was verified; general solicitation; whether the seller was registered.

⭐ The unifying question: was the risk that materialized the risk the customer was told about? Where it was not, the claim is misrepresentation regardless of suitability.

---

Tool 20 — Firm compliance self-audit

For a broker-dealer or advisory firm wanting to avoid appearing in the rest of this toolkit.

☐ Profiles current. Are objectives, time horizon, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance updated on a defined cycle and after life events? ☐ Exception reports reviewed and documented. Concentration, turnover, cost-to-equity, senior alerts — and a recorded supervisory response to each. ☐ Product due diligence files current, with internal risk ratings and any holding-period guidance. ☐ Compensation disclosure accurate and delivered, including differential compensation across comparable products. ☐ Rollover recommendations documented, with the comparison to the existing plan. ☐ Outside business activities collected, reviewed, and periodically re-confirmed. ☐ Private securities transactions approved or prohibited, in writing. ☐ Correspondence review covering the channels representatives actually use, including messaging applications. ☐ Branch inspections on schedule, with findings tracked to closure. ☐ Heightened supervision for representatives with disciplinary history, documented. ☐ Trusted contact information collected, and hold procedures trained. ☐ Complaint handling — logged, investigated, escalated, and reported. ☐ Annual training on the best-interest obligation and on the products actually sold.

⚠ The pattern in every contested case: the system either produced a documented supervisory response to a flag, or it produced nothing. The first is the best defense available; the second is the claimant's strongest exhibit.

See professional licensing and occupational discipline for the individual licensing consequences that follow, and reporting misconduct and preserving a retaliation claim for employees who raise concerns internally.

---

Tool 21 — Quick reference card

1. Do not liquidate before the damages analysis.
2. The new account form is the standard; get every version.
3. Concentration, turnover, and cost-to-equity are the three numbers that matter.
4. Compare to a benchmark the documented objectives support.
5. Check the solicited or unsolicited box on every confirmation.
6. Selling away turns on the supervisory record.
7. An unregistered sale may yield rescission without proving fraud.
8. The six-year eligibility rule runs from the events.
9. Request a reasoned award at the prehearing conference.
10. Participate in the expungement proceeding.

Tool 22 — Money-never-invested protocol

Where the "investment" was fictitious rather than merely unsuitable.

Recognizing it: statements not from a custodian; steady returns regardless of market conditions; difficulty withdrawing; pressure to reinvest; checks payable to an individual or an unrelated entity; new investor money funding old investor distributions.

Immediately:

☐ Stop sending money. ☐ Preserve everything — statements, emails, texts, wire confirmations, promotional materials, and the names of everyone who introduced the opportunity. ☐ Report to the state securities regulator, the federal agency, and law enforcement. ☐ Notify any bank that processed transfers, in writing. ☐ ⚠ Do not quietly accept a make-whole payment; it may be recoverable later as a fraudulent transfer under 11 U.S.C. § 548. ☐ Note clawback exposure for investors who withdrew profits before the collapse.

Recovery sources, in order of productivity:

1. A broker-dealer liable for a representative's selling away.
2. A financial institution that ignored obvious red flags.
3. Professionals — accountants, lawyers, appraisers — who lent credibility.
4. Receivership or bankruptcy distributions, typically cents on the dollar and years later.
5. Criminal restitution, ordered often and collected rarely.

⚠ The perpetrator is almost never a recovery source. Pursue the parties who were solvent, insured, and positioned to prevent it.

See responding to fraud, a scam, or financial exploitation and detecting, reporting, and unwinding elder financial exploitation.

---

Tool 23 — Client instruction sheet

Give this to the customer at the first meeting.

Do: ☐ Tell your lawyer everything, including anything embarrassing. ⭐ A problem known in advance is manageable; one that surfaces on cross-examination is not. ☐ Keep receiving and keeping statements. ☐ Forward anything the firm sends without responding to it. ☐ Write down what you remember about the conversations, with dates, now.

Do not: ⚠ Do not liquidate or move the account without advice. ⚠ Do not sign anything the firm sends, including an updated profile. ⚠ Do not continue trading in the same strategy — it supports a ratification defense. ⚠ Do not discuss the case publicly or on social media. ⚠ Do not delete emails or messages.

Expect: ☐ Twelve to eighteen months to a hearing. ☐ Questions about your education, occupation, other accounts, and prior investing experience. ☐ A hearing of one to five days. ☐ A settlement discussion, likely including confidentiality and an expungement request. ☐ A final award reviewable only on the narrow grounds of 9 U.S.C. § 10.

---

Related Documents

• The Broker Who Knew Better: How Investment Loss Claims Are Actually Recovered
• Investor Rights and Securities Claims: A Comprehensive Guide to Suitability, Fraud, Arbitration, and Remedies
• Investigating Investment Losses and Filing a Securities Claim: A Practical Checklist
• The Arbitration Agreement and Award Toolkit
• The Fraud Response and Financial Exploitation Toolkit
• The Elder Financial Exploitation Response Toolkit