Opinion · Supreme Court of the United States

Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc. v. Public Util. Dist. No. 1 of Snohomish Cty.

Morgan Stanley Cap. Grp. Inc. v. Pub. Util. Dist. No. 1 of Snohomish Cty., 554 U.S. 527 (2008)

Type
Opinion
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Date
2008-06-26
Topic
general

How later courts describe this case

  • explaining that courts “afford great deference” to FERC’s interpretation and application of “just and reasonable”
  • explaining that, “instead of setting forth rate schedules or rate-fixing contracts,” market-based tariffs “simply state that the seller will enter into freely negotiated contracts with purchasers” (citation omitted)
  • describing fraud and duress as “traditional grounds for the abrogation of [a] contract” that speak to “unfair dealing at the contract formation stage”
  • rejecting the “obviously indefensible proposition that a standard different from the statutory just-and-reasonable standard applies to contract rates”
  • describing fraud and duress as "traditional grounds for the abrogation of [a] contract” that speaks to "unfair dealing at the contract formation stage”
  • referring to filed rates based on private agreements as “contract rates”—as opposed to “tariff rates”—and referring to the agreements themselves as “contracts”
  • characterizing as “obviously ’ indefensible” the “proposition that a standard different from the statutory” standard applies in a subset of cases covered by the standard
  • collecting cases and applying remand futility doctrine when denying petition for review

Citator

UpLaw has not yet analyzed Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc. v. Public Util. Dist. No. 1 of Snohomish Cty.. The absence of a flag is not a finding that it is good law.

Cited by
171 opinions

Headnotes

  1. Energy & Utilities Law — Federal Power Act Under the Mobile-Sierra doctrine, FERC must presume that the rate set out in a freely negotiated wholesale-energy contract meets the "just and reasonable" requirement of the Federal Power Act, and that presumption may be overcome only if FERC concludes that the contract seriously harms the public interest. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  2. Energy & Utilities Law — Mobile-Sierra Presumption — Scope The Federal Power Act establishes only one statutory standard for assessing wholesale electricity rates, whether set by contract or by tariff — the just-and-reasonable standard — and the Mobile-Sierra doctrine reflects a differing application of that standard to contract rates, not a different standard altogether. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  3. Energy & Utilities Law — Mobile-Sierra Presumption — Timing of Challenge The Mobile-Sierra presumption that a contract rate is just and reasonable applies regardless of when the contract is challenged; it is not conditioned on FERC having had an initial opportunity to review the contract rate without the presumption, because FERC's passive permission for a rate to take effect does not constitute a finding that the rate is just and reasonable. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  4. Energy & Utilities Law — Mobile-Sierra Presumption — Market Dysfunction The Mobile-Sierra presumption is not withheld merely because a contract was formed in an environment of market dysfunction; the mere fact that the market is imperfect or chaotic is no reason to undermine the stabilizing force of contracts, and a rule keyed to market dysfunction lacks support in the Court's cases and undermines the role of contracts in the Federal Power Act's statutory scheme. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  5. Energy & Utilities Law — Public Interest Standard — Fraud, Duress, and Illegal Conduct FERC may set aside a contract rate on traditional grounds for abrogation such as fraud or duress, and where a party's illegal market activity directly affects contract negotiations and alters the playing field for those negotiations, the Mobile-Sierra presumption should not apply, because such unlawful activity eliminates the premise that the contract rates are the product of fair, arms-length negotiations. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  6. Energy & Utilities Law — High-Rate Challenges — Standard of Review The standard for a purchaser's challenge to a contract rate as too high must generally be the same as the standard for a seller's challenge: the contract rate must seriously harm the public interest, and the three Sierra factors are neither exclusive nor precisely applicable to a purchaser's high-rate challenge. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  7. Energy & Utilities Law — Mobile-Sierra Presumption — Marginal Cost A "zone of reasonableness" test that sets aside a contract rate whenever consumers' bills exceed what they would have been had the contract rate equaled marginal cost misreads Sierra and is impermissible, because setting aside a contract rate under the Mobile-Sierra presumption requires a finding of unequivocal public necessity or extraordinary circumstances, not merely that the rate exceeds marginal cost. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  8. Energy & Utilities Law — Excessive Burden — Down-the-Line Analysis In determining whether a contract rate imposes an excessive burden on consumers, FERC must consider not only whether rates increased immediately upon the contract's taking effect, but also whether the contract imposes an excessive burden "down the line" relative to the rates consumers could have obtained but for the contract after elimination of the dysfunctional market, because the unequivocal public necessity justifying override of the Mobile-Sierra presumption does not disappear once the contract enters into force. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)
  9. Energy & Utilities Law — Market Manipulation — Causal Connection The mere fact that a party engaged in unlawful activity in the spot market does not deprive its forward contracts of the Mobile-Sierra presumption; FERC may not abrogate a contract on that ground without finding a causal connection between the unlawful activity and the contract rate, but where causality is established the presumption should not apply. 554 U.S. 527 (2008)