Opinion · Supreme Court of the United States

Gelfert v. National City Bank of NY

Gelfert v. Nat’l City Bank of NY, 313 U.S. 221 (1941)

Type
Opinion
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Date
1941-04-28
Topic
general

How later courts describe this case

  • observing, in rejecting challenge to state deficiency law, that “[m]ortgagees are constitutionally entitled to no more than payment in full”
  • "[T]he advantages of a forced sale" are not "a . . . property right" under the Constitution
  • "[T]he price which property commands at a forced sale may be hardly even a rough measure of its value"
  • “while equity will not set aside a sale for mere inadequacy of price, it will do so if the inadequacy is so great as to shock the conscience or if there are additional circumstances against its fairness”

Citator

UpLaw has not yet analyzed Gelfert v. National City Bank of NY. The absence of a flag is not a finding that it is good law.

Cited by
99 opinions

Headnotes

  1. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause A state statute requiring a deficiency judgment after a foreclosure sale to be computed by deducting from the debt the greater of the fair and reasonable market value of the property, as determined by the court, or the sale price does not violate the Contract Clause as applied to a mortgage executed before its enactment, even where the mortgagee purchased the property at the foreclosure sale for much less than the debt and would previously have been entitled to a deficiency measured by the sale price. 313 U.S. at 231
  2. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause The validity under the Contract Clause of a statute regulating the measure of a deficiency judgment does not depend on a declared public emergency, nor is it defeated by the statute's confinement of the deficiency determination to the foreclosure proceeding without leaving the mortgagee an alternative remedy substantially co-extensive with that afforded under prior law. 313 U.S. at 231
  3. Remedies — Foreclosure Sales — Inadequacy of Price Equity will not set aside a foreclosure sale for mere inadequacy of price, but will do so if the inadequacy is so great as to shock the conscience or if there are additional circumstances against its fairness, such as chilled bidding. 313 U.S. at 232
  4. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause There is no constitutional reason why the legislature may not, in lieu of the more restricted control exercised by a court of equity over judicial sales, substitute a uniform rule designed to prevent mortgagees bidding at foreclosure sales from obtaining more than their just due. 313 U.S. at 233
  5. Constitutional Law — Legislative Power The formula for determining the amount of a deficiency judgment that exists at the date a mortgage is executed does not become so embedded in the contract that it cannot be constitutionally altered; existing laws are read into contracts to fix obligations between the parties, but the reservation of essential attributes of sovereign power is also read into contracts as a postulate of the legal order. 313 U.S. at 231
  6. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause Mortgagees are constitutionally entitled to no more than payment in full, and the Contract Clause does not protect the strategical, procedural advantage of retaining the benefits of a forced sale so as to recover more than the amount of their contracts. 313 U.S. at 233
  7. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause A statute measuring a deficiency by the fair and reasonable market value of the mortgaged property bears an obvious and direct relation to the mortgagee's prospective loss, and incidental individual inequality in the application of such a valuation standard does not render the statute unconstitutional; the appropriateness of a particular valuation formula is peculiarly a matter for legislative determination. 313 U.S. at 232-233
  8. Constitutional Law — Contracts Clause The Federal Constitution does not prevent the states from determining, on due notice and opportunity to be heard, by what process legal rights may be asserted or legal obligations enforced; accordingly, requiring that the right to a deficiency judgment be determined in the foreclosure proceeding, or that a mortgagee move for a deficiency or lose it, raises no substantial federal question. 313 U.S. at 233