Opinion · New York Court of Appeals

Frees v. . Ford

Frees v. . Ford, 6 N.Y. 176 (New York Court of Appeals 1852)

Type
Opinion
Court
New York Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction
New York
Date
1852-04-05
Topic
general

* Johnson, J. — There is a ground on which this -* judgment ought to be reversed, leaving untouched the question of the constitutionality of the judiciary act, so far as it relates to the jurisdiction of the . county, courts. We ought not. to pass upon the ^ ^question - of. the constitutionality. of-.a statute, unless the determination of the point is' necessary to the determination of the cause. Indeed, we cannot, if we would, so pass upon it, as to render our decision efficient as authority, when there is another and clear ground on which our judgment may be supported. The 30th section of the judiciary act provides, that the county courts- shall have jurisdiction “to hear, try and determine, according to law, the following actions, when all of the defendants, at the time of commencing the action, reside in the county in which said court is held; actions of debt, assumpsit and covenant, when the debt or damages claimed shall not exceed two thousand dollars,” &c. This county court is not a court of-general jurisdiction, as was the old court of common -pleas;-on the contrary,- it is a new court, with & limited, statutory jurisdiction, To all such courts- the-rule universally applies, that their jurisdiction must appear upon the record.

Citator

Cited by
30 opinions