Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

The most-cited opinions of the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on UpLaw — 5,689 decisions from 1892–2024, each with its treatment history and the cases that cite it.

• Deboles v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. 552 F.2d 1005 · cited by 26
• Irving B. Gruber v. Owens-Illinois Inc. 899 F.2d 1366 · cited by 26
• United States v. Terrell Davis 726 F.3d 434 · cited by 26
• The Cromar Company v. Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation and Atlantic Richfield Company 543 F.2d 501 · cited by 26
• New Jersey Education Ass'n v. Burke 579 F.2d 764 · cited by 26
• Bergen Drug Company Inc., a New Jersey Corporation v. Parke, Davis & Company, a Michigan Corporation 307 F.2d 725 · cited by 26
• United States v. HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF PITTSBURGH 186 F.3d 376 · cited by 26
• Doctors, Inc. v. Blue Cross Of Greater Philadelphia 490 F.2d 48 · cited by 26
• Joan M. Kuzmin v. Richard Schweiker, Secretary of Health and Human Services 714 F.2d 1233 · cited by 26
• United States v. Isaac Rivera 357 F.3d 290 · cited by 26
• 17 Fair empl.prac.cas. 1252, 17 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 8576 John R. Novotny v. Great American Federal Savings & Loan Association, John A. Virostek, Joseph E. Bugel, John J. Dravecky, Daniel T. Kubasak, Edward J. Lesko, James E. Orris, Joseph A. Prokopovitsh, John G. Micenko and Frank J. Vanek 584 F.2d 1235 · cited by 26
• Cotler v. Inter-County Orthopaedic Ass'n 526 F.2d 537 · cited by 26
• Sabree Ex Rel. Sabree v. Richman 367 F.3d 180 · cited by 26
• United States v. Thomas L. Monaco 23 F.3d 793 · cited by 26
• James E. Gottshall v. Consolidated Rail Corporation 56 F.3d 530 · cited by 26
• GOVERNMENT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS v. ASTARTE DAVIS, Appellant; UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. RICE, ASTARTE Astarte Davis, Appellant 43 F.3d 41 · cited by 26
• Conrad Peter, in No. 88-3797 v. Hess Oil Virgin Islands Corp., in No. 88-3798 903 F.2d 935 · cited by 26
• In re Assets of Martin 1 F.3d 1351 · cited by 26
• Garber v. Lego 11 F.3d 1197 · cited by 26
• United States v. David M. Pharis Edward J. Habina William M. Dull Harry Gangloff 298 F.3d 228 · cited by 26
• Henry Hughes v. Local No. 11 of International Association of Bridge, Structural and Ornamental Ironworkers, Afl-Cio 287 F.2d 810 · cited by 26
• Vanguard Telecommunications, Inc. v. Southern New England Telephone Company Csx Corporation, and Lightnet 900 F.2d 645 · cited by 26
• United States v. Anthony J. Pivorotto, John Robert Woods. John Robert Woods 986 F.2d 669 · cited by 26
• Thomas G. Parry Bh-2648 v. Frederick Rosemeyer 64 F.3d 110 · cited by 26
• Hudson v. Robinson 678 F.2d 462 · cited by 26
• Schweitzer v. Consolidated Rail Corp. 758 F.2d 936 · cited by 26
• In the Matter of Establishment Inspection of Kulp Foundry, Inc. Appeal of Kulp Foundry, Inc. In 81-2450. Appeal of Secretary of Labor in 81-2451 691 F.2d 1125 · cited by 26
• United States v. Housing Foundation of America, Inc. 176 F.2d 665 · cited by 26
• United States ex rel. Russo v. State of New Jersey 351 F.2d 429 · cited by 26
• Joseph ROCCO, Appellant, v. Margaret M. HECKLER, Secretary of Health and Human Services 826 F.2d 1348 · cited by 26
• Electrical Products Division of Midland-Ross Corporation v. National Labor Relations Board 617 F.2d 977 · cited by 26
• United States v. Government of the Virgin Islands 363 F.3d 276 · cited by 26
• In Re Armstrong World Industries, Inc. 432 F.3d 507 · cited by 26
• GN Netcom, Inc. v. Plantronics, Inc. 930 F.3d 76 · cited by 26
• Hugh Leroy Dunbar, Jr., A/K/A H. L. Dunbar v. United States of America, Defendants-Third Party J. Arthur Hawkesworth, Jr., Third Party 502 F.2d 506 · cited by 26
• Travelers' Ins. Co. of Hartford v. Nax 73 C.C.A. 649 · cited by 26
• Stern v. Nix 840 F.2d 208 · cited by 26
• In Re John Paul Minarik 166 F.3d 591 · cited by 26
• Commerce Bank Harris Savings Association v. Mountain View Village, Inc. Property Management, Inc., Mountain View Village, Inc. 5 F.3d 34 · cited by 26
• Wooler v. Citizens Bank 274 F. App'x 177 · cited by 26
• United States v. Walter A. Connor, Jr. 898 F.2d 942 · cited by 26
• Charangeet Singh-Kaur v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General United States of America 385 F.3d 293 · cited by 26
• Daggett v. Kimmelman 811 F.2d 793 · cited by 26
• United States v. William T. Smith, Jr. And Alan R. Stoneman. Appeal of John Doe 787 F.2d 111 · cited by 26
• Angela Borrell v. Bloomsburg University 870 F.3d 154 · cited by 26
• Cooper Distributing Co. v. Amana Refrigeration, Inc. 180 F.3d 542 · cited by 26
• United States v. Michener 152 F.2d 880 · cited by 26
• United States v. Mike Mustafa A/K/A Darwish Mustafa 238 F.3d 485 · cited by 26
• In Re: Warfarin Sodium Antitrust Litigation John Kusnerik Sara Altman Samuel Gordon Tischler Marie A. Steckel Robert Bareiss John Civatte, Jr. Mary Banten 214 F.3d 395 · cited by 26
• Oughton v. National Labor Relations Board 118 F.2d 486 · cited by 26
• Myers, Kevin v. State Farm Insurance Company 842 F.2d 705 · cited by 26
• Webster Eisenlohr, Inc. v. Kalodner 145 F.2d 316 · cited by 26
• United States v. William Farrell 126 F.3d 484 · cited by 26
• In Re Torwico Electronics, Inc., Debtor. Torwico Electronics, Inc. v. State of New Jersey, Department of Environmental Protection 8 F.3d 146 · cited by 26
• 21 Employee Benefits Cas. 1073, Pens. Plan Guide (Cch) P 23942h Frank C. Schoonejongen Wesley L. Losson John S. Dunning William Martone William v. Hanzalek Edward F. Ziek Melvin Deblock Joseph Colquhoun Joseph Majerscak Gerard Abbamont and Olga Wolsey, on Behalf of Themselves and All Others Similarly Situated v. Curtiss-Wright Corporation 143 F.3d 120 · cited by 26
• Isbrandtsen Co., Inc. v. Local 1291 of International Longshoremen's Ass'n 204 F.2d 495 · cited by 26
• D.R., by His Parents and Guardians M.R. And B.R. v. East Brunswick Bd. Of Educ. 109 F.3d 896 · cited by 26
• United States v. Daniel Touby, United States of America v. Lyrissa Touby 909 F.2d 759 · cited by 26
• Mario G. COMUSO; Marvin I. Barish, Esquire, Appellant, v. NATIONAL RAILROAD PASSENGER CORPORATION 267 F.3d 331 · cited by 26
• United States v. William Dahl 833 F.3d 345 · cited by 26
• United States v. Stevenson Stone Bey, Frederick Howard, Stevenson Stone Bey 437 F.2d 188 · cited by 26
• Houck v. Stickman 625 F.3d 88 · cited by 26
• Archibald Kreiger and Claire R. Kreiger v. United States 539 F.2d 317 · cited by 26
• In Re Philadelphia Newspapers, LLC 599 F.3d 298 · cited by 26
• Coar v. Kazimir 990 F.2d 1413 · cited by 26
• Murphy v. American Barge Line Co. 169 F.2d 61 · cited by 26
• Donna Javitz v. County of Luzerne 940 F.3d 858 · cited by 25
• United States v. Merrill H. Klein A/K/A "Morrie" Appeal of Carl Luick 515 F.2d 751 · cited by 25
• In Re School Asbestos Litigation 842 F.2d 671 · cited by 25
• Westinghouse Electric Corp. v. United Electrical Radio and MacHine Workers of America 194 F.2d 770 · cited by 25
• Beverly Enterprises, Inc. Donald L. Dotson v. Rosemary Trump Service Employees International Union Local 585 182 F.3d 183 · cited by 25
• Howard Bateman and Marguerite B. Jones, Partners, Trading as Ernest Jones Company v. Ford Motor Company 302 F.2d 63 · cited by 25
• Ammond, Alene S., in Her Capacity as a Member of the Senate of New Jersey and Individually v. Joseph L. McGahn 532 F.2d 325 · cited by 25
• In Re: Google Inc. Cookie Plac v. 934 F.3d 316 · cited by 25
• Henry Saludes v. Evelyn Ramos, M.D., and Government of the Virgin Islands. Appeal of Government of the Virgin Islands 744 F.2d 992 · cited by 25
• Parks v. Mr. Ford 556 F.2d 132 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lansdowne Swim Club 894 F.2d 83 · cited by 25
• John MacDonald v. Cashcall Inc 883 F.3d 220 · cited by 25
• United States v. Di Pasquale 864 F.2d 271 · cited by 25
• National Labor Relations Board v. Wallick 198 F.2d 477 · cited by 25
• Herring v. United States 424 F.3d 384 · cited by 25
• Rhonshawn Jackson v. Unit Manager Whalen 568 F. App'x 85 · cited by 25
• Luxliner P.L. Export, Co. v. RDI/Luxliner, Inc. 13 F.3d 69 · cited by 25
• Evans v. Hudson Coal Co. 165 F.2d 970 · cited by 25
• Acosta v. Honda Motor Co. 717 F.2d 828 · cited by 25
• William A. Kubrick v. United States 581 F.2d 1092 · cited by 25
• United States v. Daniel K. Cless, Margaret J. Cless, Elwood A. Sterner, Marion L. Sterner, C. Hoerner Cassel 254 F.2d 590 · cited by 25
• VICI Racing, LLC v. T-Mobile USA, Inc. 763 F.3d 273 · cited by 25
• United States v. Margolis 138 F.2d 1002 · cited by 25
• Cohen v. City of Philadelphia 736 F.2d 81 · cited by 25
• United States v. Gabriel Guerrero 803 F.2d 783 · cited by 25
• United States v. Anthony J. Costanzo 625 F.2d 465 · cited by 25
• Gisela Carino v. Marc Stefan, Esq Butsavage & Associates, LLC 376 F.3d 156 · cited by 25
• United States of America Government of the Virgin Islands v. Michael McKie at No. 96-7010, Jermaine Hall, at No. 96-7011, Guy M. Henry, at No. 96-7014 112 F.3d 626 · cited by 25
• Skelly Oil Co. v. Universal Oil Products Co. 31 F.2d 427 · cited by 25
• United States of America in No. 83-5233 v. Anthony J. Costanzo. Appeal of Anthony J. Costanzo in Nos. 82-5767, 83-5341/42 740 F.2d 251 · cited by 25
• United States v. Andrew Gera 409 F.2d 117 · cited by 25
• Hodge v. United States 554 F.3d 372 · cited by 25
• United States Ex Rel. Trinler v. Carusi 166 F.2d 457 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lawrence Janiec, in No. 74-1281 Appeal of Samuel Laytham, in No. 74-1282 505 F.2d 983 · cited by 25
• Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation v. Michael D. Tarbuck 62 F.3d 538 · cited by 25
• United States v. Belki Maria Vasquez De Reyes 149 F.3d 192 · cited by 25
• In re Universal Minerals Inc. 755 F.2d 309 · cited by 25
• 14 Fair empl.prac.cas. 518, 13 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 11,466, 1 Employee Benefits Ca 1537 Gladys E. Rogers and Margaret A. Rogers, as Co-Executrices of the Estate of Dilworth T. Rogers, in No. 76-1115, Cross-Appellants in No. 76-1114 v. Exxon Research and Engineering Company, a Delaware Corporation, in No. 76-1115, Cross-Appellee in No. 76-1114 550 F.2d 834 · cited by 25
• United States v. Michael Busic, United States of America v. Anthony La Rocca, Jr. 587 F.2d 577 · cited by 25
• Ferrero U.S.A., Inc. v. Ozak Trading, Inc. Doron Gratch 952 F.2d 44 · cited by 25
• In the Matter of Martin M. Decker and Kathleen H. Decker, Individually and Jointly, Bankrupts. Appeal of Martin M. Decker 595 F.2d 185 · cited by 25
• United States v. Gabriel Werdene 883 F.3d 204 · cited by 25
• United States v. Dicker, Leon 853 F.2d 1103 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lorgio D. Morales, Jr. United States of America v. Luis L. Viera. United States of America v. Luis L. Viera 861 F.2d 396 · cited by 25
• United States v. Ozcelik 527 F.3d 88 · cited by 25
• United States v. James Anderson Deans 436 F.2d 596 · cited by 25
• Xerox Corp. v. SCM Corp. 576 F.2d 1057 · cited by 25
• Covertech Fabricating, Inc. v. TVM Building Products, Inc. 855 F.3d 163 · cited by 25
• Aero Trucking, Inc. v. Regal Tube Company, and Third Party v. William Crum, Third Party 594 F.2d 619 · cited by 25
• John Gamble v. Pope & Talbot, Inc. v. Jarka Corp. Of Philadelphia. Appeal of Timothy J. Mahoney 307 F.2d 729 · cited by 25
• Madison Square Garden Corporation v. Braddock 90 F.2d 924 · cited by 25
• MCI Communications Corporation v. American Telephone & Telegraph Company and the Bell Telephone Company of Pennsylvania 496 F.2d 214 · cited by 25
• United States v. Curtis Reynolds, William Parran. Appeal of William Parran 715 F.2d 99 · cited by 25
• Xu Cheng Liang v. Immigration & Naturalization Service, Gioacchino Cinquemani v. Immigration & Naturalization Service, Carmelo Jose Rodriguez v. Immigration & Naturalization Service 206 F.3d 308 · cited by 25
• Wilson v. Beard 589 F.3d 651 · cited by 25
• United States v. Christie Industries, Inc. Edwin C. Christie. Appeal of Edwin C. Christie 465 F.2d 1002 · cited by 25
• Eugene P. Moore v. Sylvania Electric Products, Inc., a Corporation v. Keystone Electric Construction Co., Third Party 454 F.2d 81 · cited by 25
• Trucking Employees of North Jersey Welfare Fund, Inc. v. Robert Colville 16 F.3d 52 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lewis Pepperman, Trustee for Keith T. Sorensen, Keith T. Sorensen, Debtor, Us Trustee, Trustee 976 F.2d 123 · cited by 25
• United States v. Askia Washington 869 F.3d 193 · cited by 25
• United States v. Rigas 605 F.3d 194 · cited by 25
• Sommer v. the Vanguard Group 461 F.3d 397 · cited by 25
• Gorman v. Cerasia 2 F.3d 519 · cited by 25
• Waggaman v. General Finance Co. 116 F.2d 254 · cited by 25
• Cooper Laboratories, Inc. v. International Surplus Lines Insurance Company 802 F.2d 667 · cited by 25
• Garcia v. Attorney General of United States 665 F.3d 496 · cited by 25
• United States v. Matthew Metz Appeal of James Davenport 470 F.2d 1140 · cited by 25
• Bollman Hat Company v. Kevin T. Root Dale E. Anstine, P.C. Bollman Hat Company, as Sponsor of the Bollman Hat Company Health and Welfare Benefits Plan 112 F.3d 113 · cited by 25
• United States v. Sarun Cooper 396 F.3d 308 · cited by 25
• United States v. Tonelli 577 F.2d 194 · cited by 25
• DeJohn v. Temple University 537 F.3d 301 · cited by 25
• In Re Merck & Co. Securities & ERISA Litigation 493 F.3d 393 · cited by 25
• Alfred M. Sinder, Cross-Appellee v. United States of America, Cross-Appellant, and Angelo Ventrone, Third-Party 655 F.2d 729 · cited by 25
• United States v. Garden State National Bank 607 F.2d 61 · cited by 25
• Jay C. Smith v. John J. Holtz, Bureau of Technical Services, Pennsylvania State Police Ronald F. Coyler, Bureau of Technical Services, Pennsylvania State Police Victor Dove John J. Purcell, Special Agent in Charge, Central Regional Office, Bureau of Criminal Investigations, Office of the Attorney General William J. Lander, Bureau of Criminal Investigations, Office of the Attorney General Paul Yatron 210 F.3d 186 · cited by 25
• The Moravian School Advisory Board of St. Thomas, V.I. v. Helen Rawlins the Department of Labor, Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Labor, Government of the Virgin Islands, Jane Rogers, on Behalf of Herself the Estate of Ingrid Corena Rogers Nirone Pavon Francis, Minor Laurel Simone Francis, Minor v. Government of the Virgin Islands St. Thomas Hospital Elena Aguas, M.D. 70 F.3d 270 · cited by 25
• The NEW JERSEY HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, Appellant, v. William WALDMAN, Velvet Miller, Leonard Fishman 73 F.3d 509 · cited by 25
• In Re Blood Reagents Antitrust Litigation 783 F.3d 183 · cited by 25
• Franzen v. E. I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co. 146 F.2d 837 · cited by 25
• United States v. Walter Esposito 968 F.2d 300 · cited by 25
• JS Ex Rel. Snyder v. Blue Mountain School Dist. 650 F.3d 915 · cited by 25
• United States v. Andres R. Romero-Vilca 850 F.2d 177 · cited by 25
• Teamsters Local Union No. 764 v. J.H. Merritt and Company 770 F.2d 40 · cited by 25
• The United States of America v. Nicholas A. Stirone 311 F.2d 277 · cited by 25
• In Re Goody's Family Clothing Inc. 610 F.3d 812 · cited by 25
• Priscilla M. Lippincott Adams v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue 170 F.3d 173 · cited by 25
• Ogden v. United States 50 C.C.A. 380 · cited by 25
• Sheik Abdel Rahim Ahmad, Formerly Known as Clarence Hooks v. Walter W. Redman, Warden D.C.C., and Attorney General of the State of Delaware 782 F.2d 409 · cited by 25
• Baker v. United States 670 F.3d 448 · cited by 25
• In re Grand Jury Proceedings 654 F.2d 268 · cited by 25
• United States v. Samuel David Smith, III 445 F.3d 713 · cited by 25
• Heilman v. United States 731 F.2d 1104 · cited by 25
• United States v. Luis Ricardo Navarro, A.K.A "Lucho", and Porfirio Nunez-Vasquez 145 F.3d 580 · cited by 25
• Pennsylvania Medical Society v. Snider 29 F.3d 886 · cited by 25
• United States v. Rivas 493 F.3d 131 · cited by 25
• In the Matter of the President's Commission on Organized Crime Subpoena of Nicodemo Scarfo. Appeal of United States of America 783 F.2d 370 · cited by 25
• Easley v. Snider 36 F.3d 297 · cited by 25
• Agathos v. Starlite Motel 977 F.2d 1500 · cited by 25
• In Re: Nutraquest, Inc., Debtor Linda Will George Wheeler, Jr., as Independent Co-Administrators of the Estate of Rashidi Wheeler, Deceased v. Northwestern University Charles Taylor Randall Walker Jerry Brown Terrence Aggeler, Larry Lilja Thomas Christian Justin Chabot Michael Rose Mark Gardner, M.D. v. Next Proteins, Inc., F/k/a Next Nutrition, Inc., D/B/A Next Proteins International the Ultimate Orange Energy Co. LLC Ultimate Energy Co. Phoenix Laboratories, Inc. General Nutrition Corporation, D/B/A General Nutrition Companies, Inc., a Wholly Owned Subsidiary of Royalo Numico Nv, Cytodyne Technologies, Inc., N/k/a Nutraquest, Inc., Third Party Northwestern University, Charles Taylor, Randolph Walker, Jerry Brown, Terence Aggeler, Larry Lijla, Thomas Christian, Justin Chabot and Michael Rose 434 F.3d 639 · cited by 25
• Walter D. Weir and Janet D. Weir v. Federal Insurance Company, and Third Party Cross-Appellee v. Whirlpool Corporation, Third Party Cross-Appellant, and Mesa Tv and Appliance, Inc., Third Party 811 F.2d 1387 · cited by 25
• Rhoads v. Ford Motor Co. 514 F.2d 931 · cited by 25
• International Brotherhood of Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen and Helpers of America, Local 249 v. Western Pennsylvania Motor Carriers Association 660 F.2d 76 · cited by 25
• Donald White v. Sunoco Inc 870 F.3d 257 · cited by 25
• United States v. Robert Feldman 425 F.2d 688 · cited by 25
• United States of America Ex Rel. James Cannon v. James F. Maroney, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution, Pittsburgh, Pa 373 F.2d 908 · cited by 25
• Dyszel v. Marks 6 F.3d 116 · cited by 25
• Cooley, William v. Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency Gerhold, Wayne D. Smith, Karl C. And Donadee, Michael A 830 F.2d 469 · cited by 25
• United States v. Keith Cimera 459 F.3d 452 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lafferty 503 F.3d 293 · cited by 25
• United States v. David E. Napier 273 F.3d 276 · cited by 25
• United States v. Dominic Alaimo 297 F.2d 604 · cited by 25
• Plant Economy, Inc. v. Mirror Insulation Company, Inc. 308 F.2d 275 · cited by 25
• Forgione v. United States Nicastro v. United States 202 F.2d 249 · cited by 25
• James M. Tunnell, Jr., and Mildred S. Tunnell v. United States 259 F.2d 916 · cited by 25
• United States v. Robert Allen Edwards A/K/A Fidel Salim A/K/A James F. Winter, III A/K/A Charles King A/K/A Donald W. Coleman, Robert Allen Edwards 162 F.3d 87 · cited by 25
• Horton v. Flenory 889 F.2d 454 · cited by 25
• William TARASI, George Sampas and Virginia R. Harrigan, Appellants, v. PITTSBURGH NATIONAL BANK and S. Robert Mialki 555 F.2d 1152 · cited by 25
• In Re Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation. The Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, Intervenor-Defendant, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Columbia Gas System, Inc. ("Cg") and Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco" and Together With Cg, "The Debtors"), No. 92-7395. In Re Columbia Gas Systems Inc. (Fifteen Cases) Columbia Gas Systems Inc. v. Unsecured Creditors Committee, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation, National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenors in Support of Office of Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Columbia Gas Systems, Inc. ("Cg") and Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco" and Together With Cg, "The Debtors"), No. 92-7396. Meridian Oil Production Inc. v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Columbia Gas System, Inc. ("Cg") and Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco" and Together With Cg, "The Debtors"), No. 92-7397. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, the Maryland Public Service Commission, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio and the Maryland Office of People's Counsel, No. 92-7398. Maryland Office/people's Counsel v. Columbia Gas Systems, Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Productions Inc., Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation Natural Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Transmission Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, the Maryland Public Service Commission, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio and the Maryland Office of People's Counsel, No. 92-7399. Public Utilities Commission/ohio v. Columbia Gas Systems, Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc., Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the State of New York, Intervenor in Support of Public Service Commission of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, the Maryland Public Service Commission, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio and the Maryland Office of People's Counsel, No. 92-7400. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, Intervenor-Defendant, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Natural Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, West Ohio Gas Company, the Peoples Natural Gas Company and Virginia Natural Gas, Inc., No. 92-7410. West Ohio Gas Co. Virginia Natural Gas, Inc. Peoples Natural Gas Company, No. 92-7411 v. Columbia Gas Systems, Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission ("Tco"), Intervenors in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, Intervenor-Defendant, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), No. 92-7412. Official Committee of Customers of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco") v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee on Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), No. 92-7413. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, Intervenor-Defendant, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenors in Support of Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, Intervenors in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Columbia Gas of Kentucky, Columbia Gas of Maryland, Columbia Gas of Ohio, Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania, and Commonwealth Gas Services, Collectively Known as the Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, No. 92-7414. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Maryland Office of People's Counsel ("Mpc"), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corporation New York State Electric and Gas Corporation National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation, Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers of the Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Columbia Gas Distribution Companies, Intervenors in Support of Ozark Gas Transmission System, a Texas General Partnership (The "Partnership") and Its Subsidiary, Ozark Finance Corporation (The "Company"), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Maryland Public Service Commission Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Intervenors in Support of Consumer Advocate Division of the Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenors in Support of Office of the Consumers' Counsel, State of Ohio (Occ), Intervenors in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Cities of Charlottesville and Richmond, Virginia, No. 92-7415. Meridian Oil Production Inc. v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenor in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae, Ozark Gas Transmission System and Ozark Finance Corporation, No. 92-7435. Ozark Gas Transmission System Ozark Finance Corp., No. 92-7436 v. Columbia Gas Systems, Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate (Pa. Oca), Intervenor in Support of Meridian Oil Production Inc. ("Meridian Oil"), Intervenor in Support of Delmarva Power & Light Company ("Delmarva") the Providence Gas Company ("Providence"), Intervenors in Support of Office of the People's Counsel for the District of Columbia (Opc), Intervenors in Support of Official Committee of Customers ("Customer Committee") of Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation ("Tco"), Intervenor in Support of Gas Research Institute ("Gri"), Amicus Curiae. Meridian Oil Production Inc. v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Ozark Gas Transmission System and Ozark Finance Corporation, No. 92-7499, Ozark Gas Transmission System Ozark Finance Corporation, No. 92-7499. Ozark Gas Transmission System Ozark Finance Corporation, No. 92-7500 v. Columbia Gas Systems Inc. Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation, Thomas E. Ross, Trustee, Meridian Oil Production, Inc., Intervenor-Appellee 997 F.2d 1039 · cited by 25
• Evans Products Co. And Home Builders Mortgage Corp. v. West American Insurance Co. 736 F.2d 920 · cited by 25
• United States v. Smith 123 F.3d 140 · cited by 25
• United States v. Camiel 689 F.2d 31 · cited by 25
• In the Matter of Grand Jury Empanelled March 19, 1980 United States of America 680 F.2d 327 · cited by 25
• Williams v. Hilton Group PLC 93 F. App'x 384 · cited by 25
• Mario Mendoza v. United States 690 F.3d 157 · cited by 25
• Jean Levine, on Behalf of Herself and All Others Similarly Situated v. United Healthcare Corporation (Dc Nj 01-Cv-04964) 402 F.3d 156 · cited by 25
• Clientron Corp. v. Devon It, Inc. 894 F.3d 568 · cited by 25
• United States v. Lawrence D. Beverly, Larry Beverly, in No. 83-1306. United States of America v. Dorrie Eugene Adams, in No. 83-1324 723 F.2d 11 · cited by 25
• Howard Jamison, Administrator of the Estate of Albert Tucker, Deceased v. A. M. Byers Company 330 F.2d 657 · cited by 25
• Natalie F. Smith, Widow of Dennis A. Smith, Deceased v. Patricia Harris, Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare 644 F.2d 985 · cited by 25
• United States v. Angelo 153 F.2d 247 · cited by 25
• United States of America Ex Rel. Edward Doggett, 46985 v. Howard D. Yeager, Warden 472 F.2d 229 · cited by 25
• Victor M. Francois v. A. Jane Francois, George H. Adams and William H. Dick, D/B/A Ad'm Enterprises, a Limited Partnership. Appeal of A. Jane Francois 599 F.2d 1286 · cited by 25
• United States v. Joseph M. McCrane Jr. 547 F.2d 204 · cited by 25
• Government of the Virgin Islands v. Paul Mills 956 F.2d 443 · cited by 25