Rosin v. New York Stock Exchange, Inc.

How later courts describe this case

• noting that the agency must “specify in detail which portions of the document are disclosable and which are allegedly exempt.”
• granting summary judgment upon agency's representations "in candor and in good faith" that all responsive documents were made available to plaintiff
• mandating a detailed description of each document withheld and a detailed justification for why the exemption applies for each document in its entirety rather than segregable portions thereof
• requiring the government to create a public index listing privileged documents and providing explanations of the claim of privilege
• articulating the Government’s burden to produce meticulous and specific documentation of its claimed justification for nondisclosure under 5 U.S.C. § 552
• requiring “a relatively detailed analysis [of alleged exempt status] in manageable segments” to allow a court to ensure that claimed exemptions “are adequately justified[.]”
• articulating the burden to produce meticulous and specific documentation of the Department’s claimed justifications for non-disclosure under 5 U.S.C. § 552
• requiring agency to produce index specifying exemptions claimed and reasons for exemptions