Marroquin-Manriguez v. Immigration & Naturalization Service

How later courts describe this case

• holding that the scope or conduct of discovery is within the sound discretion of the district court
• allowing equitable tolling where an employer had brought a non-frivolous constitutional challenge to the MPPAA on an issue not previously decided
• "The Court's method of analysis in Turner Elkhorn Mining represents a fundamental shift from that employed in Alton Railroad."
• a district court has broad discretion in determining the manner in which discovery is conducted.
• the scope and conduct of discovery are within the sound discretion of the trial court
• availability of information under FOIA would undercut the showing of need necessary under 8 C.F.R. § 287.4(a)(2)
• “MPPAA ... protects the interlocking interests of the PBGC, the premium payers, the withdrawing employers and the vested employees.”
• law prohibiting local liquor advertising directly advances government’s interest in discouraging liquor consumption despite fact that residents are exposed to liquor advertising from out-of-state sources