Opinion · Supreme Court of North Carolina

State v. . Dove

222 N.C. 162

Type
Opinion
Court
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jurisdiction
North Carolina
Date
1942-10-14
Topic
general

How later courts describe this case

  • court ordered mistrial since evidence desired by State “was not presently available”

Citator

UpLaw has not yet analyzed State v. . Dove. The absence of a flag is not a finding that it is good law.

Cited by
12 opinions
Per Curiam.

Tbe defendant was indicted for murder. However, at tbe solicitor’s election be was not put on trial for first degree murder but for murder in tbe second degree or manslaughter. This was equivalent to taking a nolle prosequi on tbe capital charge. S. v. Gregory, 203 N. C., 528, 166 S. E., 387. At tbe close of tbe State’s evidence defendant’s motion for judgment as of ndnsuit was denied. Tbe solicitor then moved to be permitted to offer additional testimony. This motion was allowed, and, it appearing that tbe evidence desired was not presently available, tbe court ordered a mistrial, and continued tbe case. Tbe defendant excepted to tbe ruling of tbe trial judge, and appealed to this Court.

Tbe ordering of a mistrial in a case less than capital is a matter in tbe discretion of tbe court. S. v. Johnson, 75 N. C., 123; S. v. Upton, 170 N. C., 769, 87 S. E., 328; S. v. Ellis, 200 N. C., 77, 156 S. E., 157; S. v. Guice, 201 N. C., 761, 161 S. E., 533; S. v. Watson, 209 N. C., 229, 183 S. E., 286: In capital cases only is tbe judge required to find tbe facts and place them on record so that upon a plea of former jeopardy tbe action of 'the court may be reviewed. S. v. Tyson, 138 N. C., 627, 50 S. E., 456; S. v. Beal, 199 N. C., 278 (295), 154 S. E., 604.

It is apparent that tbe appeal is premature and must be dismissed. S. v. Andrews, 166 N. C., 349, 81 S. E., 416; S. v. Ford, 168 N. C., 165, 83 S. E., 831.

Appeal dismissed.