Opinion · Supreme Court of the United States

Ramah Navajo School Bd., Inc. v. Bureau of Revenue of NM

Ramah Navajo Sch. Bd., Inc. v. Bureau of Revenue of NM, 458 U.S. 832 (1982)

Type
Opinion
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Date
1982-07-02
Topic
bankruptcy

How later courts describe this case

  • noting that the Johnson-O’Malley Act is one of “numerous statutes empowering the [Bureau of Indian Affairs (‘BIA’)] to provide for Indian education both on and off the reservation”
  • applying doctrine where state imposed gross receipts tax on receipts that non-Indian construction company, hired to build reservation school, received from tribal school board
  • upholding an Indian Tribe's challenge to a state's attempt to tax the gross receipts a non-Indian construction company received from constructing a school on reservation property to educate tribal children
  • discussing Congress’s “broad power . . . to regulate tribal affairs under the Indian Commerce Clause”
  • construing a gross receipts tax on construction services as being imposed on tribal lands where the construction was taking place
  • applying and developing tests in context of state taxation of reservation sales to non-Indians
  • State prohibited from imposing gross-receipts tax on a non-Indian contractor constructing an on-reservation tribal school
  • state gross receipts tax imposed on private contractor’s proceeds from the construction of a school on the reservation

Citator

UpLaw has not yet analyzed Ramah Navajo School Bd., Inc. v. Bureau of Revenue of NM. The absence of a flag is not a finding that it is good law.

Cited by
177 opinions

Headnotes

  1. Native American Law — Taxation Federal and tribal interests arising from Congress's broad power to regulate tribal affairs under the Indian Commerce Clause and from the semi-autonomous status of Indian tribes may pre-empt state authority over commercial activity on a reservation; these interests erect two independent but related barriers to state authority, in that state law may be pre-empted by federal law or may interfere with the tribe's ability to exercise its sovereign functions. 458 U.S. at 837-838
  2. Native American Law — Pre-emption Analysis Pre-emption analysis of state authority over reservation activity is not controlled by mechanical or absolute conceptions of state or tribal sovereignty but requires a particularized examination of the relevant federal, state, and tribal interests, informed by traditional notions of tribal sovereignty and by congressional Acts promoting tribal independence and economic development; ambiguities in federal law should be construed generously, and federal pre-emption is not limited to situations where Congress has explicitly announced an intention to pre-empt state activity. 458 U.S. at 838-839
  3. Native American Law — Federal Pre-emption of State Tax The comprehensive federal regulatory scheme governing the construction of Indian schools, together with the express federal policy of encouraging tribal self-sufficiency in education, leaves no room for the additional burden imposed by a state gross receipts tax on payments made by a tribal school board to a non-Indian contractor for construction work on the reservation; the fact that federal statutes and regulations do not specifically express an intention to pre-empt this exercise of state authority does not defeat pre-emption. 458 U.S. at 839-842
  4. Native American Law — Taxation A State's interest in providing services to a non-Indian contractor for activities conducted off the reservation is not a legitimate justification for a tax whose ultimate economic burden falls on the tribal organization, nor is the State's general desire to increase revenues sufficient to justify additional burdens on the comprehensive federal scheme regulating educational opportunities for Indian children and on the express federal policy of encouraging Indian self-sufficiency in education. 458 U.S. at 843-845
  5. Native American Law — Pre-emption Analysis Existing pre-emption analysis governing state taxation of reservation activity need not be replaced by a new approach relying on the Indian Commerce Clause, because that analysis is sufficiently sensitive to federal, state, and tribal interests, provides sufficient guidance to state courts, and allows for more flexible consideration of the interests at issue. 458 U.S. at 845-846